Blog
Replace Just the Doors, Reface, or Replace Everything? How to Decide
If your cabinet boxes are solid and you like your layout, replacing the doors and drawer fronts, or refacing, gets you most of the visual change with far less work. If the boxes are damaged, the layout doesn’t work, or you’re replacing the countertops anyway, full replacement is usually the better call. The deciding factor is the condition of what’s behind the doors.
The Three Options in Plain Terms
1. Replace the doors and drawer fronts
You keep the existing boxes, face frames, shelves and countertops. You swap in new doors and drawer fronts, usually with new hinges and pulls. The face frames get painted to match or contrast, or are left as-is if they already work with the new doors.
2. Reface
Refacing includes everything in option 1, plus covering the exposed parts of the old cabinets: the face frames and the finished end panels. That’s typically done with wood veneer, a thin "skin" panel on the ends, or paint. Done well, the cabinets look like a new set.
3. Replace everything
The old cabinets come out. Countertops, sink, cooktop and dishwasher are disconnected and removed. New boxes go in, and countertops are usually replaced too, since stone and solid-surface tops often don’t survive removal intact.
Side-by-Side Comparison
| New doors only | Reface | Full replacement | |
|---|---|---|---|
| What changes | Doors, drawer fronts, hinges, pulls | Doors, fronts, face frames, end panels, hardware | Everything, often including counters |
| What stays | Boxes, frames, counters, layout | Boxes, counters, layout | Usually nothing but walls and floors |
| Effort level | Lowest; a weekend project for many DIYers | Moderate; veneer work takes patience | Highest; multiple trades involved |
| Kitchen downtime | Minimal; kitchen stays usable | Short; counters and sink stay in service | Significant; kitchen out of commission |
| Layout changes possible | No | No | Yes |
| Fixes damaged boxes | No | No | Yes |
Check the Boxes Before You Decide
Doors and refacing only make sense if the boxes are worth keeping. Empty a few cabinets and look closely:
- Under the sink. Look for swollen, crumbling or soft bottoms. Particleboard that has gotten wet doesn’t recover. A single damaged sink base can sometimes be replaced on its own while the rest stays.
- Shelves. Sagging shelves can be replaced; that alone isn’t a reason to tear out a kitchen.
- Face frames. Check that joints are tight and the frames are flat. Loose frames can often be reglued and screwed.
- Square openings. Hold a framing square in a few openings. Badly racked boxes make new doors hard to line up.
- Drawer boxes. Worn drawers and slides can be replaced separately. See Replacing a Broken Cabinet Drawer Box.
If most boxes pass, you’re a candidate for doors or refacing.
When New Doors Alone Make Sense
- The face frames are in good shape and can be painted.
- You’re happy with the layout and the countertops.
- You want a different door style or color, or the old doors are dated, damaged or yellowed.
- You’re updating a rental unit and need durable, fast results with minimal downtime.
This is the most common path for DIY homeowners and landlords. Most of the work is measuring carefully, removing old doors, and hanging new ones. Our guide on How to Measure for Replacement Cabinet Doors (Overlay Math Made Simple) walks through the sizing.
When Refacing Is Worth the Extra Work
- The face frames are stained wood that won’t match the new doors, and you don’t want to paint them.
- The exposed end panels are worn, chipped or a different color than the new look.
- You want the finished cabinets to read as a cohesive new set rather than "new doors on old cabinets."
Refacing adds veneer or skin panels and more careful finish work, so it takes more time than doors alone. Many homeowners compromise: new doors, painted frames, and new skin panels only on the visible ends.
When to Replace Everything
- Boxes have water damage, delamination or structural problems.
- The layout doesn’t work: no drawers where you need them, a dead corner, appliances that don’t fit.
- You’re changing the footprint, moving plumbing or adding an island.
- You’re replacing countertops anyway, which removes one of the biggest reasons to keep the old boxes.
- You want features that require different boxes, such as deep drawer stacks or full-extension pull-outs that won’t fit your existing openings.
A Middle Path Many People Miss
You don’t have to choose one option for the whole room. Common hybrids:
- New doors throughout, plus one or two new cabinets where the old ones were damaged.
- New doors on the uppers, and converting a base cabinet to drawers.
- New doors and fronts, plus new drawer boxes so the drawers work as well as they look.
FAQ
Can I put new doors on cabinets with exposed hinges? Often yes. Concealed hinges made for face-frame cabinets let you switch from old exposed hinges. Confirm the hinge style and overlay before you order.
Will new doors look out of place on old cabinets? Not if the face frames and end panels are finished to match. See New Doors on Old Boxes: Making Them Match.
Is refacing just veneer over the old doors? No. Refacing replaces the doors and drawer fronts and covers the frames and ends. The old doors are discarded.
Who installs them? Doors and drawer fronts are a manageable DIY job. If you’d rather not, hire your own installer or handyman.
Start With the Doors
If your boxes are solid, new doors are the biggest change you can make with the least disruption. Browse our Cabinet Doors in 9 wood species and 64 thermal foil (RTF) colors, made to your exact sizes with no minimum order, and request samples to see color and finish in your own light. Questions? Email information@craftedcabinet.com.